Subaru vs. Mazda Reliability

When it comes to choosing a reliable vehicle on Long Island, two Japanese automakers often rise to the top of the list: Subaru and Mazda. Both offer standout engineering, stylish designs, and advanced safety-but which brand gives you more confidence in the long run?

At South Shore Subaru, we're taking a deep dive into how Subaru stacks up against Mazda when it comes to reliability, maintenance, resale value, and everyday performance in New York driving conditions.

Long-Term Reliability: Subaru vs. Mazda

According to industry sources like Consumer Reports and J.D. Power, Subaru and Mazda consistently rank near the top for reliability. But there's a key difference:

• Subaru vehicles are known for their rugged durability, built with long-lasting components that hold up over 100,000 miles-especially in rough weather or tough terrain.

• Mazda, while also reliable, emphasizes sporty handling and sleek design, but may not offer the same all-weather resilience or drivetrain longevity as Subaru's symmetrical AWD system.

Winner: Subaru - Better suited for long-term ownership in Northeast conditions.

Standard All-Wheel Drive vs Front-Wheel Drive

This is where Subaru really separates itself.

• Subaru offers standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive on nearly every model (excluding BRZ). This gives drivers superior traction in rain, snow, or on gravel roads-perfect for Long Island winters.

• Mazda uses front-wheel drive as standard, with AWD only available as an optional upgrade on select trims.

Winner: Subaru - More dependable for year-round, all-weather driving.

Maintenance Costs and Ownership Experience

When it comes to the cost of ownership, both brands do well-but again, Subaru comes out ahead in critical areas.

• Subaru's engines are engineered for longevity, and when paired with the VIP+ Program here at South Shore Subaru (which includes free oil changes, inspections, and more), your maintenance costs stay low.

• Mazda models may require more frequent brake and tire servicing depending on how they're driven, especially on sportier trims.

Winner: Subaru - Lower cost of ownership with dealer-backed perks.

Safety & Reliability Ratings

Both brands shine when it comes to safety-but reliability gives Subaru the edge.

• Subaru EyeSight® Driver Assist Technology is standard on most models, and the brand routinely earns IIHS TOP SAFETY PICK+ honors across the lineup.

• Mazda also performs well in crash tests, but lacks some of the standard safety tech Subaru includes at no extra cost.

Winner: Subaru - Safer out of the box, with a stronger history of consistent safety scores.

Resale Value & Brand Loyalty

• Subaru has some of the highest resale values in the industry, with Kelley Blue Book awarding it multiple "Best Resale Value" honors.

• Mazda performs moderately well, but typically depreciates faster than Subaru in the used market.

Winner: Subaru - Stronger long-term value retention.

Conclusion: Subaru Is Built to Go the Distance

While both Subaru and Mazda are reliable brands with strong reputations, Subaru consistently delivers better long-term reliability, all-weather performance, and safety-all of which are vital for drivers in Long Island, Lindehurst, Wantagh, Babylon, and beyond.

Test Drive a Reliable Subaru Today at South Shore Subaru

Ready to experience a vehicle that's built to last? Visit South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst, NY, and explore our full lineup of dependable, all-wheel-drive Subaru models. Whether you're looking for a Crosstrek, Outback, or Forester, we'll help you find the perfect fit.

📍 305 Sunrise Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY
✅ 4.9-Star Rated Dealership
🚗 Huge Inventory + VIP+ Program Perks